police investigation procedure, investigation under BNSS, Section 175 BNSS, Section 176 BNSS, criminal investigation in India, police investigation process, criminal defence advocate in Surat

Police Investigation in India: Procedure, Powers & Rights Under BNSS

Police investigation is one of the most important stages of a criminal case in India. After information regarding a cognizable offence is recorded, the investigating police officer may collect evidence, examine witnesses, inspect the place of occurrence, identify suspects, collect documentary and electronic material, obtain forensic evidence and take other steps permitted by law.

Since 1 July 2024, criminal procedure in India is principally governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). The provisions relating to police investigation are primarily contained in Sections 175 to 193 BNSS, although other provisions may apply depending on the facts and nature of the offence.

Important: Police investigation is a process of collecting and evaluating material relating to an alleged offence. The registration of an FIR or the commencement of an investigation does not by itself establish the guilt of an accused person.

What Is Police Investigation?

Police investigation means the process through which the investigating agency examines the facts and circumstances surrounding an alleged offence and collects material that may be relevant to the criminal case.

The investigation can involve several steps, including inspection of the scene, examination of witnesses, collection of documents, recovery of articles, forensic examination, analysis of electronic evidence and questioning of persons connected with the case.

The precise steps depend on the nature of the offence, the available evidence and the circumstances of the individual case.

Who Can Conduct a Police Investigation?

Under Section 175 BNSS, the officer in charge of a police station may investigate a cognizable case without obtaining a prior order of a Magistrate, where the statutory requirements relating to jurisdiction are satisfied.

The Superintendent of Police may, considering the nature and gravity of the offence, require a Deputy Superintendent of Police to investigate the case.

A Magistrate also has powers under the BNSS to order an investigation in appropriate circumstances and subject to the statutory procedure.

How Does Police Investigation Begin?

Where information is received or otherwise comes to the notice of the police and there is reason to suspect the commission of an offence which the police are empowered to investigate, Section 176 BNSS sets out the investigation procedure.

The police officer is required to send the prescribed report to the competent Magistrate and may proceed personally or through an authorized subordinate officer to the place of occurrence to investigate the facts and circumstances of the case.

Where necessary, the investigating officer may also take lawful measures for discovering and arresting the alleged offender.

Important Steps in Police Investigation

1. Visiting the Place of Occurrence

The investigating officer may visit the location connected with the alleged offence and examine the surrounding circumstances.

Depending on the case, the officer may document the scene, identify relevant objects, collect material evidence and undertake other investigative steps permitted by law.

2. Examination of Witnesses

Police may examine persons who appear to be acquainted with the facts and circumstances of the case.

Section 179 BNSS permits an investigating police officer to require the attendance of certain persons by written order where they appear to have relevant information. The provision also contains safeguards regarding the place of attendance for certain categories of persons.

For example, women, persons below fifteen years or above sixty years, persons with mental or physical disabilities and persons with acute illness generally cannot be required to attend a place other than their residence, subject to the statutory provisions.

3. Recording Statements

Statements of witnesses may be recorded during investigation in accordance with the BNSS.

Such statements form part of the investigation material and may become relevant during later court proceedings in accordance with the rules governing their use.

4. Collection of Documentary Evidence

Investigators may collect documents relevant to the alleged offence. Depending on the case, this may include agreements, bank records, invoices, ownership documents, medical records, correspondence and other documentary material.

5. Collection of Electronic Evidence

Modern criminal investigations may involve substantial electronic evidence. Depending on the allegations, investigators may examine CCTV footage, mobile phones, computers, emails, messages, digital transactions, call-related records and other electronic material.

Electronic evidence must be collected, preserved and presented in accordance with the applicable procedural and evidentiary law.

6. Forensic Investigation

Forensic evidence can be particularly important in serious criminal cases. It may include fingerprints, DNA-related material, biological samples, weapons, documents, digital evidence and other scientific material depending on the offence.

Section 176(3) BNSS provides for forensic expert visits and videography in investigations concerning offences punishable with imprisonment of seven years or more, from the date notified by the concerned State Government, subject to the statutory framework and availability of forensic facilities.

7. Search, Seizure and Recovery

During investigation, police may undertake lawful searches and seize or recover articles that may be relevant to the alleged offence, subject to the applicable statutory safeguards and procedural requirements.

The seized material may subsequently become part of the prosecution case and may be produced before the court where legally required.

8. Arrest During Investigation

Arrest may take place during an investigation where the legal requirements for arrest are satisfied. An FIR or investigation does not automatically mean that every person named or suspected must be arrested.

The necessity and legality of arrest depend on the facts of the case and the applicable provisions of the BNSS and other law.

Can Police Investigate Without a Magistrate's Order?

For a cognizable case, Section 175 BNSS permits the officer in charge of a police station to investigate without an order of a Magistrate, subject to the statutory requirements.

The position is different for a non-cognizable case. Under Section 174 BNSS, police ordinarily require an order of the competent Magistrate before conducting an investigation into a non-cognizable case.

What Happens During a Non-Cognizable Case?

When information regarding a non-cognizable offence is given to the police, Section 174 BNSS provides for recording the information and referring the informant to the Magistrate.

Police cannot investigate a non-cognizable case without the order of a Magistrate having the necessary jurisdiction, subject to the provisions of the BNSS.

Where a case involves two or more offences and at least one of them is cognizable, the BNSS provides that the case is treated as a cognizable case for the purpose specified by the provision.

What Is the Police Case Diary?

Section 192 BNSS requires every police officer conducting an investigation under the relevant chapter to make day-to-day entries in the investigation diary.

The diary records matters such as the time information was received, the time investigation began and ended, places visited and circumstances ascertained during the investigation.

Statements of witnesses recorded during investigation are also inserted in the case diary as provided by the law.

A criminal court may call for the police diary to aid an inquiry or trial, but the diary is not itself treated as substantive evidence merely because it is maintained by the investigating officer.

Can the Police Decide Not to Investigate?

The BNSS recognizes circumstances in which an officer may conclude that there is not sufficient ground for entering upon an investigation.

Where the officer does not fully comply with the ordinary investigation procedure in the situations specified under Section 176, reasons are required to be recorded in the prescribed manner, and the statutory reporting requirements must be followed.

Where information is not properly acted upon, the BNSS also provides remedies, including the statutory route to the Superintendent of Police and, in appropriate circumstances, an application to the Magistrate.

What Happens After the Investigation Is Completed?

After completing the investigation, the police must prepare and forward the report required by Section 193 BNSS to the competent Magistrate.

The police report generally contains the information and material required by law concerning the investigation and the persons involved.

Depending on the evidence collected, the police may place the case before the court for prosecution or submit the appropriate final report in accordance with law.

How Long Can Police Take to Complete an Investigation?

Section 193 BNSS states that every investigation must be completed without unnecessary delay.

The BNSS also prescribes a specific two-month investigation period for certain offences, including specified offences under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and certain offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012, as specified in Section 193(2).

For other cases, the applicable statutory provisions and circumstances of the case determine the investigation timeline. Delays may have legal consequences in appropriate circumstances, including issues relating to statutory/default bail where the applicable conditions are satisfied.

Police Investigation and the Rights of an Accused

An accused person remains entitled to the protections provided by the Constitution and applicable criminal procedure throughout the investigation.

The fact that a person is being investigated does not by itself mean that the person is guilty. The defence may challenge unlawful investigative action and may seek appropriate remedies available under law.

Depending on the circumstances, legal remedies may include anticipatory bail, regular bail, applications concerning unlawful arrest or detention, discharge at the appropriate stage, and other remedies available before the competent court.

What Should a Person Do During a Police Investigation?

  • Keep copies of important documents connected with the case.
  • Preserve relevant electronic evidence and avoid unnecessary alteration or deletion of data.
  • Obtain proper legal advice where there is a risk of arrest or prosecution.
  • Do not sign documents without understanding what they are and why they are being provided.
  • Do not create, alter or destroy evidence.
  • Maintain records of important communications with the investigating agency.
  • Comply with lawful notices and court orders while preserving all available legal remedies.

What If the Investigation Is Unfair or Improper?

If a person believes that the investigation involves serious procedural irregularity, unlawful action or other grounds requiring judicial intervention, appropriate legal remedies may be available before the competent court.

The remedy depends on the nature of the grievance. Depending on the case, a person may approach the Superintendent of Police, the Magistrate or a higher court under the applicable statutory and constitutional provisions.

Police Investigation vs Criminal Trial

Police Investigation Criminal Trial
Primarily conducted by the investigating agency. Conducted before the competent criminal court.
Evidence and investigative material are collected. Evidence is presented and tested according to law.
Witnesses may be examined by police. Witnesses may be examined and cross-examined in court.
Ends with a police report under the applicable law. May result in conviction, acquittal or another judicial outcome.

Role of a Criminal Defence Advocate During Investigation

Legal assistance can be important during the investigation stage because decisions and evidence collected during investigation can affect the later criminal proceedings.

A criminal defence advocate may assist in matters concerning anticipatory bail, regular bail, arrest and remand proceedings, responses to legal notices or police notices, protection of legal rights, discharge, quashing and other appropriate legal remedies, depending on the facts and procedural stage of the case.

Frequently Asked Questions About Police Investigation

What is police investigation in India?

Police investigation is the process through which the investigating agency examines an alleged offence and collects relevant evidence, including witness statements, documents, electronic material, forensic evidence and other information permitted by law.

Which section of BNSS deals with police investigation?

Several provisions govern investigation. Sections 175 and 176 BNSS deal with the power of police to investigate cognizable cases and the procedure for investigation, while later provisions cover witness examination, the investigation diary and the final police report.

Can police investigate a cognizable offence without a Magistrate's order?

Yes. Section 175 BNSS generally permits the officer in charge of a police station to investigate a cognizable case without an order of a Magistrate, subject to the statutory conditions.

Can police investigate a non-cognizable offence without a Magistrate's order?

Ordinarily, no. Section 174 BNSS requires an order of the competent Magistrate for police investigation of a non-cognizable case, subject to the provisions of the law.

Can police arrest a person during investigation?

Arrest may take place when the legal requirements for arrest are satisfied. An FIR or investigation does not automatically require the arrest of every person named or suspected.

What is a police case diary?

The police case diary is the investigation diary maintained by the investigating officer under Section 192 BNSS. It contains day-to-day details of the investigation and may be called for by a criminal court to aid its inquiry or trial.

What happens after police investigation is completed?

After completion of investigation, the police submit the report required under Section 193 BNSS to the competent Magistrate. The criminal case then proceeds according to the applicable court procedure.

How long does police investigation take?

Section 193 requires investigations to be completed without unnecessary delay. Specific time limits apply to certain offences, while other cases depend on the statutory framework and circumstances. Delay can have legal consequences in appropriate cases.

Conclusion

Police investigation is a fundamental stage of a criminal case. It involves collecting and evaluating material relating to an alleged offence before the matter proceeds to the next stages of the criminal justice process.

Under the BNSS, investigation may involve inspection of the scene, witness examination, collection of documentary and electronic evidence, forensic examination, search and seizure, arrest where legally justified and preparation of the final police report.

Because criminal investigations can significantly affect the rights and interests of both the accused and the victim, the legality of investigative steps and the available remedies should be assessed according to the particular facts of each case.


Legal Disclaimer: This article is provided for general educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Criminal procedure depends on the facts and circumstances of each case, and laws and judicial interpretations may change.

Official Sources: India Code and Ministry of Home Affairs – New Criminal Laws.