FIR procedure in India, difference between complaint and FIR, Section 173 BNSS, criminal complaint, Zero FIR, criminal case process, criminal defence advocate in Surat

Complaint or FIR in India: Difference, Procedure & Legal Rights

When a person becomes a victim of a crime or receives information about an alleged criminal offence, one of the first questions is whether to file a complaint or FIR. Although these terms are often used interchangeably, they have different meanings and may lead to different procedural routes under Indian criminal law.

Since 1 July 2024, criminal procedure in India is principally governed by the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). For information relating to a cognizable offence, Section 173 BNSS provides the framework for giving information to the police. A complaint, as defined in the BNSS, is an allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate with a view to taking action under the Sanhita and does not include a police report.

Important: Filing an FIR does not mean that the accused has been proved guilty. An FIR records information about an alleged cognizable offence. Guilt is determined through the legal process and, where applicable, trial and judicial evaluation of evidence.

What Is an FIR?

FIR stands for First Information Report. In common legal usage, it refers to the recording by the police of information relating to a cognizable offence.

Under Section 173 of the BNSS, information relating to the commission of a cognizable offence may be given orally or by electronic communication to the officer in charge of a police station, irrespective of the area where the offence was committed.

When information is given orally, it is reduced to writing and read over to the informant before being signed. Where information is submitted electronically, the person giving the information is required to sign it within the period prescribed by the law.

What Is a Criminal Complaint?

Under Section 2(1)(h) of the BNSS, a complaint means an allegation, made orally or in writing to a Magistrate, with a view to taking action under the BNSS, that a person, known or unknown, has committed an offence.

The statutory definition specifically provides that a complaint does not include a police report.

A complaint case may therefore begin directly before the competent Magistrate. The Magistrate may examine the complainant and consider the material placed before the court according to the procedure prescribed by the BNSS.

Difference Between Complaint and FIR

FIR Criminal Complaint
Usually relates to information about a cognizable offence given to the police. An allegation made to a Magistrate seeking action under the BNSS.
Police record the information under Section 173 BNSS. The Magistrate follows the procedure applicable to complaints.
May lead to a police investigation. May proceed as a complaint case and may also result in directions or further steps in accordance with law.
Commonly starts the police-investigation route. Commonly starts proceedings before the Magistrate.

When Should an FIR Be Registered?

Where information given to the police discloses the commission of a cognizable offence, Section 173 BNSS provides the statutory framework for recording that information.

However, the BNSS also contains a specific provision dealing with certain cognizable offences punishable with imprisonment of three years or more but less than seven years. Under Section 173(3), with prior permission from an officer not below the rank of Deputy Superintendent of Police, the officer in charge may conduct a preliminary inquiry to determine whether a prima facie case exists. The provision contemplates completion of that preliminary inquiry within 14 days.

This provision is different from the general procedure for recording information under Section 173(1) and must be considered according to the facts and the offence involved.

Can an FIR Be Filed at Any Police Station?

Section 173 BNSS states that information relating to a cognizable offence may be given to the officer in charge of a police station irrespective of the area where the offence was committed.

This provision provides statutory support for what is commonly referred to as a Zero FIR approach. The territorial jurisdiction issue can then be addressed through the legal procedure governing investigation and transfer of the case.

The Ministry of Home Affairs has also stated that Section 173 BNSS permits information relating to a cognizable offence to be given irrespective of the area where the offence was committed.

Can an FIR Be Filed Electronically?

Yes. Section 173 BNSS expressly allows information relating to a cognizable offence to be given by electronic communication. The electronic information must be signed by the person giving it within the period specified by the provision.

Therefore, in appropriate circumstances, a person may use the electronic mechanism provided by the police or applicable government system for communicating the information.

Is the Informant Entitled to a Copy of the FIR?

Yes. Under Section 173(2) BNSS, a copy of the information recorded under Section 173(1) is to be supplied forthwith and free of cost to the informant or victim.

The informant should carefully check the factual details in the recorded information and keep the copy safely for future legal proceedings.

What If the Police Refuse to Register the FIR?

If the officer in charge of a police station refuses to record information relating to a cognizable offence, the BNSS provides a further statutory remedy.

Under Section 173(4) BNSS, the aggrieved person may send the substance of the information in writing and by post to the Superintendent of Police.

If the Superintendent of Police is satisfied that the information discloses the commission of a cognizable offence, the SP may investigate the case personally or direct an investigation by a police officer subordinate to the SP.

Where the statutory process still does not provide the required relief, the aggrieved person may approach the competent Magistrate. Section 175(3) BNSS provides for a Magistrate's power to order an investigation after considering the application supported by an affidavit, making such inquiry as considered necessary, and taking into account the submission of the police officer.

What Is the Procedure for a Complaint Before a Magistrate?

A complaint may be presented before the competent Magistrate when the complainant seeks action through the complaint procedure.

The BNSS contains a separate chapter dealing with Complaints to Magistrates. The procedure includes provisions relating to examination of the complainant, postponement of issue of process, dismissal of a complaint and issue of process.

The Magistrate may therefore examine the complaint and determine the appropriate next procedural step in accordance with the BNSS and the facts of the matter.

FIR or Complaint: Which Procedure Applies?

The appropriate route depends upon the nature of the allegations, the classification of the alleged offence, the evidence available and the circumstances in which the matter is brought before the authorities.

A police FIR is generally associated with the investigation of a cognizable offence, while a complaint case is a proceeding initiated before a Magistrate by an allegation seeking judicial action.

In some situations, a person may first approach the police and, if the statutory requirements are not followed, may subsequently use the remedies available before the Superintendent of Police or the Magistrate.

What Is the Difference Between Cognizable and Non-Cognizable Offences?

The classification of an offence is important when deciding the procedural route. A cognizable offence is one for which the police may, in accordance with the applicable law, arrest without warrant.

For a non-cognizable offence, Section 174 BNSS provides a different procedure. The police enter the information and ordinarily refer the informant to the Magistrate. Police investigation into a non-cognizable case requires the order of a Magistrate having the necessary jurisdiction.

Important Steps After Filing an FIR

  1. Recording of information by the police.
  2. Supply of the recorded information to the informant or victim as provided by law.
  3. Investigation by the police where legally authorized.
  4. Collection and preservation of relevant evidence.
  5. Statements of witnesses and other investigative steps.
  6. Arrest or notice, where legally justified.
  7. Completion of investigation.
  8. Submission of the police report to the competent court.
  9. Further court proceedings according to the nature of the case.

Important Points Before Giving a Complaint or FIR

  • Provide accurate and factual information.
  • Clearly mention the relevant dates, places and persons involved.
  • Preserve documents, photographs, messages, emails, CCTV footage and other relevant evidence.
  • Keep a copy of the complaint or FIR-related application.
  • Obtain acknowledgement wherever a written representation is submitted.
  • Do not knowingly provide false information or fabricate evidence.
  • Seek legal advice where the allegations involve serious criminal consequences.

Frequently Asked Questions About Complaint or FIR

What is an FIR in India?

An FIR is commonly understood as the first formal recording by police of information relating to a cognizable offence. Section 173 BNSS governs the recording of such information.

What is a complaint under the BNSS?

A complaint is an allegation made orally or in writing to a Magistrate with a view to taking action under the BNSS. The statutory definition does not include a police report.

What is the main difference between an FIR and a complaint?

An FIR is part of the police-information and investigation route, while a complaint is an allegation made to a Magistrate seeking action under the complaint procedure.

Can an FIR be filed electronically?

Yes. Section 173 BNSS permits information relating to a cognizable offence to be given by electronic communication, subject to the statutory requirement concerning signature.

Can an FIR be filed outside the place where the offence occurred?

Section 173 BNSS states that information relating to a cognizable offence may be given irrespective of the area where the offence was committed. This is commonly associated with the Zero FIR concept.

What can I do if the police refuse to register an FIR?

Section 173(4) BNSS permits an aggrieved person to send the information in writing and by post to the Superintendent of Police. Where appropriate, the person may also seek relief before the competent Magistrate under the procedure provided by the BNSS.

Is the FIR copy free?

Section 173(2) BNSS provides that a copy of the recorded information shall be given forthwith and free of cost to the informant or victim.

Does an FIR prove guilt?

No. An FIR records allegations or information about an alleged cognizable offence. The guilt or innocence of an accused is determined through the criminal justice process and judicial evaluation of the evidence.

Conclusion

Understanding the difference between a complaint and an FIR is an important first step in dealing with a criminal matter. Under the BNSS, the police and Magistrate have different procedural roles, and the appropriate remedy depends on the nature of the offence and the facts of the case.

If the matter concerns a cognizable offence, Section 173 BNSS provides the framework for giving information to the police. If police action is not taken as required by law, the BNSS also provides statutory remedies through the Superintendent of Police and the competent Magistrate.

Because every criminal matter is fact-specific, professional legal advice should be obtained before taking significant procedural steps.


Legal Disclaimer: This article is for general legal information and educational purposes only. It is not a substitute for legal advice in a specific case. Laws, procedures and judicial interpretations may change.

Official Sources: India Code – Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and Ministry of Home Affairs – New Criminal Laws.